R.G. McGraw Insurance Agency is a downtown-based insurance agency that serves a broad mix of companies, public institutions, and high net worth individuals. We are known for delivering the best cost and coverage solutions for our clients' risk management and asset protection needs.

We deliver a superior level of professional counsel and personalized service from an experienced team that averages over 15 years of insurance knowledge, including actuarial, underwriting, and claim processing roles. Plus, we are supported by 20 well recognized insurance carriers that allow us to provide competitive, value-added recommendations to meet all of our clients' local, national, and even international risk management needs.

Since our founding in 1955, R.G. McGraw Insurance has created a unique service culture that builds long-term, trusted professional partnerships with our clients. Our highly client-centric approach ensures every client, regardless of size or scope, receives a rigorous annual analysis along with a customized insurance solution that meets their timing and financial requirements. And, it has been very successful with almost all of our growth coming from the unsolicited recommendations of past and current clients.

Fifth Third Insurance Agency Inc., an indirect, wholly owned subsidiary of Fifth Third Bancorp, acquired R. G. McGraw Insurance Agency, Inc. on March 10, 2017.


With an average of 15 years of experience in the Property and Casualty marketplace, the employees of the R. G. McGraw Insurance Agency stand ready to work with you in developing a tailored approach to managing the risks of your Business, Home & Auto Insurance programs.

We pride ourselves in developing a Personal and Responsive relationship with our clients. When you contact our office, you will deal with a trusted partner with integrity who has taken the time to get to know you and your unique insurance needs.

Howard McClure III
Outside Phone: 214-416-0408
Michael S. McGraw, CIC President CEO Business Personal Life Insurance Property & Casualty Insurance Cincinnati OH R.G. McGraw Insurance
Managing Director
Phone: 513-381-7881 x106
Clif Kennedy Account Executive Agent Business Personal Home Auto Insurance
Producer/Account Executive
Phone: 513-381-7881 x102
Graham T. Vollmer
Producer/Account Executive
Phone: 513-381-7881 x113
Mark J. Roberto, CPCU Account Executive Insurance
Account Executive
Phone: 513-381-7881 x104
Dave Dabbelt Account Executive Commercial Personal Business Home Auto Property Casualty Workers Comp
Account Executive
Phone: 513-381-7881 x109
Carolyn Nabors Account Executive Account Manager Commercial Property Casualty Auto Workers Comp
Commercial Lines Account Manager
Phone: 513-381-7881 x103
Commercial Lines Account Manager
Phone: 513-381-7881 x105
Commercial Lines Account Manager
Phone: 513-381-7881 x111
Commercial Account Manager - Small Business Unit
Phone: 513-381-7881 x112
Peggy Lampson Account Manager Personal Insurance Home and Automobile Insurance Umbrella Insurance Fine Art Insurance Boat Insurance
Personal Lines Account Manager
Phone: 513-381-7881 x120
Donna Wilson Personal Insurance Account Manager Home Auto Umbrella
Personal Lines Account Manager
Phone: 513-381-7881 x114
Kathleen Kate Bell Administrative Assistant
Administrative Assistant
Phone: 513-381-7881 x101